To buy or not to buy? That’s the question being asked in rented homes up and down the country. Conventional wisdom says it’s better to be a homeowner than a home renter, because your monthly home payment goes towards an asset that you own. But in today’s topsy-turvy, credit-crunch world, is it always better to buy than to rent?

For Rent
Renting Pros
* Recent research by Abbey shows it’s cheaper to rent a typical first-time buyer property than to buy one in London and East Anglia.
* You don’t have the worry of shelling out for unexpected maintenance bills, it’s just the household utilities and council tax to keep on top of. If it’s your home, you’re the landlord, and the cost is all on you!
* Renting gives you the flexibility and freedom to relocate whenever and wherever you need – and at the drop of a hat if necessary. Homeowners are likely to face a long wait to sell their property in the current market.
* Renting might be a better option for anyone worried about the security of their job. Most rental contracts last six months and sometimes offer notice periods, giving people whose circumstances change, the option to find somewhere cheaper to live more quickly if the worst should happen.
* If you need to relocate to a new area, renting a place gives you a chance to get to know the location without tying you down to staying there long term.
* While owning your own home might make better financial sense in the long run, it’s a big commitment. If you rent and fancy taking a career break to travel the world, for example, there’s nothing to stop you!
Renting Cons
* One of the biggest downsides to renting are the fees you have to pay upfront. Having to stump up deposits and rent in advance can be tricky.
* Money paid in rent pays off your landlord’s mortgage, not yours, leaving you with nothing to show for your cash.
* There’s no guarantee that you will be able to stay in the property when your six month tenancy runs out. In the worst-case scenario, you could find yourself homeless even sooner if your landlord fails to keep up with their mortgage, leaving you with all the hassle and cost of having to find somewhere else to live.
* Getting your deposit back from the landlord can be difficult. You’ll often have to shell out for professional cleaners and ensure the whole house is practically perfect in order to receive a full refund.
* Putting your personality into a property can be hard if you’re not allowed to decorate. Some landlords will let you paint rooms, but others ban you from hanging new pictures on the walls, let alone refreshing the colour scheme.
* When something does go wrong, it’s up to the landlord to sort it. While this can be blissful because someone else has to deal with the problem and pay for it, you may have to wait for them to sort it out, which doesn’t always happen instantly.
Buying Pros
* Property is cheaper. House prices have fallen by more than 20% since the market peaked, so if you buy now, you’re definitely getting a better deal than you would have done 18 months ago.
* Interest rates have been slashed to a record low, making mortgage repayments more affordable than they have been for years. But one thing you can be sure about is that rates will be on their way back up at some point in the future, so it might be worth considering taking out a fixed rate mortgage if you want to ensure your payments don’t rise. Compare mortgage deals for a great rate with Confused.com.
* The money you spend on housing every month goes towards paying off your own mortgage. This is an investment in your future, rather than your landlord’s, so you’re gradually acquiring an asset.
* Recent research by Abbey has shown it’s now cheaper to buy a typical first-time buyer property than rent one in all areas of the country except East Anglia and London.
* In the current climate, sellers are prepared to accept hefty discounts on their asking prices, particularly if they think the value of their home is falling by the day. Be warned though, as soon as the market stabilises, people will be less likely to do this.
* The Government introduced a one-year stamp duty holiday in September last year for properties costing up to £175,000 – saving people buying a home of this value £1,750.
* Being a homeowner can help build up your credit rating, as you can demonstrate to potential lenders that you’re able to keep up with your monthly debt commitments.
* If you have a spare room you could always make some extra cash by renting it out. Under the Government’s rent a room scheme you can receive £4,250 a year tax-free.
Buying Cons
* The costs associated with buying a home are big. There’s a temporary stamp duty exemption on properties costing up to £175,000, but you will have to pay the tax on properties costing more than this. There are also solicitors’ fees and moving costs to consider, as well as mortgage arrangement fees, which all add up.
* The days of lenders being happy to advance high loan-to-value (LTV) mortgages are long gone, so you will have to save up a deposit if you want to buy a home. A few mortgage deals still remain for people with a 5% deposit but you will pay high rates on these. If you’re looking for a competitive deal, you will need to put down at least 20% of your home’s value – no small undertaking.
* Whereas renters don’t have the worry of shelling out for unexpected maintenance bills, if it’s your home, you’re the landlord, and the cost is on you! You will also have to pay for building insurance.
* It’s difficult to sell properties in the current market, making it hard to change location if you need to move in a hurry, especially if you’re holding out for a decent price.
* It’s less easy to take a career break if you own a property as you’re tied down to a mortgage. However, you could consider renting out your home while you are away, and you might even make some money doing this if you have a low mortgage.
* You could fall into negative equity, meaning the value of your home drops below that of your mortgage, making it difficult for you to sell up and move on if you want to.
The last word
In the current market, it’s important to try to disengage yourself from the mania surrounding homeownership. Instead, focus on whether now is the right time for you to buy a home, or whether your circumstances mean you’d be better off renting for a bit longer.